Resolution Systems InstituteResolution Systems InstituteMenuDonate
  • Home
  • About
    • Overview
    • Mission
    • People
    • History
    • Awards
    • Careers
    • Support RSI
  • Services
    • Program Administration
    • Program Design
    • Research and Evaluation
  • Our Impact
    • Child Protection Mediation
    • Evaluation of a Child Protection Mediation Program
    • Eviction Mediation
    • Foreclosure Mediation
  • Resource Center
    • Overview
    • Court ADR Basics
    • Guide to Program Success
    • Mediation Efficacy Studies
    • Model Surveys
    • The OPEN Project: ODR Party Engagement
    • Peer Review Tools
    • Special Topics
  • Publications
  • Blog
  • Contact
  • Donate
Combined ShapeBack to search results

The Effect of Victim-Offender Mediation on Severity of Reoffense

Nugent, William R.; Paddock, Jeffrey B.. Mediation Quarterly, Jan. 1, 1995

The article discusses a study into the relationship between participation in a victim-offender reconciliation program (VORP) and subsequent reoffense by children and adolescents. Two groups of cases were compared - those that participated in a VORP and those that went through a more traditional juvenile justice approach. The study found that VORP participants are less likely to reoffend within a year of their mediation, and if they reoffend, they tend to commit less serious offenses than children and adolescents who go through a more traditional approach.

Description of Study: Looked at the impact of mediation on the recidivism rate and severity of reoffense in juvenile cases in Anderson County, TN.

Method: Examined case records. Controlled for family structure, race, age, gender, last grade completed, number of prior offenses, number of siblings. Mediated and non-mediated cases were matched on the type of crime and admission of guilt.

Comparative: Yes

Comparison Groups: A random sample of juveniles who mediated their cases (approximately 65% of all referred cases) after admitting responsibility and a random sample of juveniles who appeared in court and pleaded guilty prior to the inception of the program

Sample Size: 125 of a population of 193 mediated cases; 150 of a population of 448 non-mediated cases

Variables Examined: Frequency of reoffense, severity of reoffense

Program Variables: Voluntary, free program. Study looked at cases that were filed from the program’s inception in 1986 through the end of 1988.

Findings: The reoffense rate was 19.8% in mediated cases, 33.1% in non-mediated cases. Level 3 (most severe) reoffenses were committed by 5.4% of offenders who participated in mediation, 3.8% of offenders who did not.

11 E Adams Street, Suite 500, Chicago, IL 60603

  • 312.922.6475
  • info@aboutrsi.org
  • © 1998-2025 RSI
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

To give you the best possible experience, this site uses cookies. If you continue browsing, you accept our use of cookies and agree to our Disclaimer, Privacy & Copyright policy.

Learn More